Casa Rustica

World-famous Lobster Flambé, Authentic Sicilian Cuisine, Original Craft Cocktails and Much More!

Proudly serving the great village of Smithtown, New York since 1985!

Outside Dining, Takeout, Curbside Pickups and Private Parties are Always Available!


Enjoy our signature, modern and traditional creations

Dinner Menu

Authentic Sicilian cuisine and our famous lobster flambé

Lunch Menu

Enjoy a wide range of delicious lunch selections

Dessert Menu

Go ahead, indulge yourself in our classic desserts

Contact Us

Have a question? Want to make a reservation? Get in touch!

What People are Saying

“Amazing Experience”

We had a great dining experience tonight.
I had their lobster flambé which was absolutely delicious!


“Ambience is Perfect”

“Wife had a table side prepared 2 lb. lobster in a brandy and cognac cream sauce, the waiter took the cooked lobster out of the shell and sautéed the lobster meat in the brandy and cognac and then returned the meat back into the shell for presentation back to the table. Very nicely done. “


“Great Spot!”

“Great little spot. Went for lunch. Had a fantastic veal chop! I don’t eat lobster but people rave about it. Meatballs are on point.”



“We recently had a small celebration at Casa Rustica. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about the food and service, which were outstanding. We have eaten here many times over the years and always enjoy it.